• #1
• Comment by Ari

That looked like an orange not an lemon? Which one did you intend to use.

• #2
• Comment by ariun

Looks like a lemon to me!

• #4
• Comment by parshu.narayanan

Looks delicious. Are there any restaurants in Italy-Switzerland that serve this, particularly in the larger towns?

• #5
• Comment by Raoul

We love your website. Each of us in our office intently await the arrival of your next recipe. Keep up the great work!-Raoul

• #7
• Comment by Assissotom

This is one of the best sites I have ever found. Thanks!!! Very nice and informal. I enjoy being here.

• #8
• Comment by HeatherL

This sounds interesting.. do you cook the stew w/the egg yolks at all?

• #10
• Comment by Tony

"Here our friends the Irish have no excuse for not having come up with a similar dish!"Ummm what? I am constantly astounded that people who consider themselves to be well informed make ridiculous assumptions about cuisines from different countries based on what I can only assume to be ignorance or acceptance of stereotyping.  Irish traditional cuisine is a rich cuisine and there are many ongoing debates as to what constitutes "classic" dishes. Remarks like this smack of being ill informed and badly researched.... or perhaps deliberately insulting....and please don't refer to Mr Paul Rankin as an exponent of Irish Cuisine, without a doubt responsible for huge travesties in mangling traditional recipies. See Rachel Allen, Darina Allen et al for some great traditional Irish cuisine.

• #12
• Comment by Tony

The same ingredients? I don't think Irish cuisine has lemons(?). We also do not have Tomatoes or Garlic as native ingredients. We also do not have olive oil. We have great root vegetables, smoked goods, meats, bakery and dairy. I would be *very* interested to hear what you would class as being "the same" ingredients! The point with a lot of traditional Irish food is to taste the basic ingredients, hence the quality of these is paramount. Don't get me wrong I love Italian and French cuisine (though have been veering towards cantonese food lately) - Indeed when I make stew I do use garlic and red wine (which my mother thinks is heresy!). You can not make statements such as you have when the comparison is not valid. The reason for no lemons in traditional Irish cuisine is that we didn't have lemons :O). A cuisine must be viewed in context. What cookbooks did you buy? I'd be interested to hear. There are many, many abominable books, and very few good ones. Most pander to the touristy perception of the Irish, and of traditional "Irish fare". You should also realise that by reading a recipe you have not tasted it! some things sound much worse than they taste ;O)

• #14
• Comment by Tony

No no, you misunderstand me. The point I was making was that Irish Stews have been around for a long, long time. As such the truly traditional stews do not contain lemon, or Garlic (at least not in the traditional sense of farmed Garlic, wild garlic is native - but as I'm sure you know that is a tad different from the bulb Garlic we all know and love, chives and parsley are native and also sometimes used) as they predate the introduction of these ingredients as food staples. The basic traditional stew was even viewed good enough to be included in Escoffier's Guide Culinaire.Of course these recipes have evolved, stout being added, ale being added, garlic (bulb) etc. As I mentioned I use red wine and Garlic in addition to lamb stock. I also flour and brown the meat (though it has to be said browning and flouring etc is in some old recipes). You are correct insofar as good vinegar though.... potted herrings being a favourite of mine :o) Herrings from Ardglass of course ;)You mention cheeses, and I have to say in the last few years cheese making as a cottage industry has really taken off. It is great to be able to buy good local cheese on a regular basis, as opposed to having to seek it out on days out. Old skills are being relearned as more and more people realise what is available in terms of source ingredients. Beer making here is taking off too. We have a few good local  breweries (ales and stouts mostly), but my preference is for wheat beer - so for the moment I'm still drinking my belgian/dutch beers (Korenwolf, Weinstephaner, Ayinger and Paulander. Hoegaarden at a push...) Anyhow, do keep the recipes coming :o)

• #15
• Comment by NN

Hi! The sauce sounds a whole lot like Greek "avgolemono", which my mother and granma make a wonderful soup from (as well as a terrific tart sauce for dolmades!)

• #17
• Comment by Soraya Johnson

Hi! I absolutely LOVE this website, and the pictures are amazing! I am going to make this stew for 7 people, and I was wondering how much of each ingredient I should buy and in what proportions I should use them. Thanks!

• #18
• Comment by ian

I made this myself, with a few modifications - shallots with the garlic and parsley at the end - but I didn't get the same intense yellow color. I think it was because I let the braising liquid reduce before adding the egg and lemon, or because I cooked it in a cast iron pot. Any ideas?

• #19
• Comment by Jan

Hi FX,
I made this today but the sauce was very runny. It tasted great though, so I'd like to make it again. I wasn't really sure how long to cook it once the wine and water were in there, because the lamb was ready pretty quickly. (I guess I should use bigger chunks of meat, less liquid?) Thanks for all the awesome recipes.